
“Do not admit a charge against an elder except on the evidence of two or three witnesses.” (1 Timothy 5:19 (ESV)
The following devotional is by Pastor J. Ligon Duncan. Dr. Duncan serves as the Chancellor of Reformed Theological Seminary in Jackson, Miss. This excerpt is taken from a sermon he preached in 2004 entitled Accountable Leadership from I Timothy 5:17-25.
No unsubstantiated accusations are to be entertained against pastor/elders. It’s
a directive for due process in charges against the minister, or the
ministers or elders, of the church. His point is that uncorroborated charges
against a pastor/elder should not be entertained. “Do not receive an accusation
against an elder except on the basis of two or three witnesses.”
Now again, this comes right out of the Old Testament civil law. One of the protections of justice in Israel was that you couldn’t simply make an anonymous charge, or a charge that could only be corroborated by the person bringing the charge, and have it entertained before a judge in Israel. You had to have witnesses. There had to be some proof of the reality of the charge that was being brought against a person.
Paul is appealing to that same principle. He’s saying, “If that’s the case in the nation-state of Israel, certainly it ought to be the case in the church. We shouldn’t allow unsubstantiated charges.” Obviously, ministers and elders are put into circumstances where it would be rather easy to make an unsubstantiated charge against them, and here Paul says only corroborated accusations are to be considered in the process of discipline.
Now, what do we learn from this? Well, obviously we learn how we are to proceed in cases of charges against ministers. But we also learn something else, friends. You know, so often we say, “Oh, if it could only be in our church like it was in the days of the early Church.” You know, we think of all the problems that are in the Church today. Back then, everything was wonderful.
Well, look. Here’s Paul writing to a congregation thirty years
after the ascension of Christ; less than thirty years after Pentecost and the
outpouring of the Holy Spirit. And what’s he writing to them about? He’s
writing about how to handle charges against elders; how to handle discipline of
elders; how to find out when elders have actually seriously sinned publicly.
He’s talking about a church that has problems! Its officers are being accused of
serious sins.
There has never been a perfect local church on earth, and there never will be. We’ll never be in a perfect church until the age to come is here; until we are in glory, we’ll never see a perfect church. Now, that’s so important, because very often in the Christian life we are deeply disappointed by the shortcomings of our local church in various ways. And very often the reason for that is we have unrealistic expectations about how it is going to be to live and minister together.
We think that Christians are always going to act like Christians in the local church. And isn’t it beautifully freeing to realize that Paul envisages a circumstance where even serious charges can be brought against the leaders of the church, and it does not compromise the reality of the gospel preached or of the work of Christ in the midst of this body. It’s a real encouraging thing, if you’ll think about it. We need to be realistic about the church.
The church, the local church, is never going to be perfect. There are always going to be issues and problems, and even serious sins. That doesn’t mean that we become complacent about those sins, but it does mean we live in a fallen world, and the fall has impacted the church as well. And so, Paul gives us a reality check here, even as he tells us not to accept uncorroborated charges against a pastor or elder.
May the Lord’s truth and grace be found here. Have a blessed day in the Lord.
Soli deo Gloria!















